The Cryosphere Discussions www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net 1994-0432 1994-0440 4 1 2010 10.5194/tcd-4-77-2010 http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/4/77/2010/ http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/4/77/2010/tcd-4-77-2010.html http://www.the-cryosphere-discuss.net/4/77/2010/tcd-4-77-2010.pdf 77 119 2010-01-27 Applicability of time-lapse refraction seismic tomography for the detection of ground ice degradation C. Hilbich chilbich@geo.uzh.ch Institute for Geography, University of Jena, Germany Institute for Geography, University of Zurich, Switzerland The ice content of the subsurface is a major factor controlling the natural hazard potential of permafrost degradation in alpine terrain. Monitoring of changes in ground ice content is therefore similarly important as temperature monitoring in mountain permafrost. Although electrical resistivity tomography monitoring (ERTM) has proved to be a valuable tool for the observation of ground ice degradation, results are often ambiguous or contaminated by inversion artefacts. In theory, the P-wave velocity of seismic waves is similarly sensitive to phase changes between unfrozen water and ice. Provided that the general conditions (lithology, stratigraphy, state of weathering, pore space) remain unchanged over the observation period, temporal changes in the observed travel times of repeated seismic measurements should indicate changes in the ice and water content within the pores and fractures of the subsurface material. In this paper, the applicability of refraction seismic tomography monitoring (RSTM) as an independent and complementary method to ERTM is analysed for two test sites in the Swiss Alps. The development and validation of an appropriate RSTM approach involves a) the comparison of time-lapse seismograms and analysis of reproducibility of the seismic signal, b) the analysis of time-lapse travel time curves with respect to shifts in travel times and changes in P-wave velocities, and c) the comparison of inverted tomograms including the quantification of velocity changes. Results show a high potential of the RSTM approach concerning the detection of altered subsurface conditions caused by freezing and thawing processes. For velocity changes on the order of 3000 m/s even an unambiguous identification of significant ground ice loss is possible. Burger,~H R., Sheehan,~A F., and Jones,~C H.: Introduction to Applied Geophysics – Exploring the Shallow Subsurface, W W Norton and Company, Inc., London, 554~pp., 2006. Delaloye,~R.: Contribution à l'étude du pergélisol de montagne en zone marginale, Ph.D. thesis, Département de Géosciences – Géographie, Fribourg, University of Fribourg, 242~pp., 2004. Delaloye,~R. and Lambiel,~C.: Evidences of winter ascending air circulation throughout talus slopes and rock glaciers situated in the lower belt of alpine discontinuous permafrost (Swiss Alps), Norsk Geogr. Tidsskr., 59(2), 194–203, 2005. Delaloye,~R., Reynard,~E., and Lambiel,~C.: Pergélisol et construction de remontées mécaniques: l'exemple des Lapires (Mont-Gelé, Valais), Le gel en géotechnique, Publications de la Société Suisse de Mécanique des Sols et des Roches, 141, 103–113, 2001. Fortier,~R., Allard,~M., and Seguin,~M K.: Effect of physical-properties of frozen ground on electrical-resistivity logging, Cold. Reg. Sci. Technol., 22(4), 361–384, 1994. Harris,~C., Arenson,~L U., Christiansen,~H H., Etzelmüller,~B., Frauenfelder,~R., Gruber,~S., Haeberli,~W., Hauck,~C., Hoelzle,~M., Humlum, ~O., Isaksen,~K., Kääb,~A., Kern-Lütschg,~M A., Lehning,~M., Matsuoka,~N., Murton,~J B., Noetzli,~J., Phillips,~M., Ross,~N., Seppälä,~M., Springman,~S., and Vonder Mühll,~D.: Permafrost and climate in Europe: Monitoring and modelling thermal, geomorphological and geotechnical responses, Earth-Sci. Rev., 92, 117–171, 2009. Harris,~C. and Cook,~J D.: The detection of high altitude permafrost in Jotunheimen, Norway using seismic refraction techniques: An assessment, Arctic Alpine Res., 18(1), 19–26, 1986. Harris,~C. and Isaksen,~K.: Recent warming of European permafrost: Evidence from borehole monitoring, in: Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Permafrost, Fairbanks, Alaska, 1, 655–661, 2008. Harris,~C., Vonder Mühll,~D., Isaksen,~K., Haeberli,~W., Sollid,~J L., King,~L., Holmlund,~P., Dramis,~F., Guglielmin,~M., and Palacios,~D.: Warming permafrost in European mountains, Global Planet. Change, 39(3–4), 215–225, 2003. Hauck,~C.: Geophysical methods for detecting permafrost in high mountains, Ph.D. thesis, Mitteilungen der Versuchsanstalt für Wasserbau, Hydrologie und Glaziologie der Eidgenössischen Technischen Hochschule Zürich, Nr 171, ETH Zürich, 204~pp., 2001. Hauck,~C.: Frozen ground monitoring using DC resistivity tomography, Geophys. Res. Lett., 29(21), 2016, doi:10.1029/2002GL014995, 2002. Hauck,~C., Bach,~M., and Hilbich,~C.: A~4-phase model to quantify subsurface ice and water content in permafrost regions based on geophysical data sets, in: Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Permafrost, Fairbanks, Alaska, 1, 675–680, 2008. Hauck,~C., Isaksen,~K., Mühll,~D V., and Sollid,~J L.: Geophysical surveys designed to delineate the altitudinal limit of mountain permafrost: an example from Jotunheimen, Norway, Permafrost Periglac., 15(3), 191–205, 2004. Hauck,~C. and Vonder Mühll,~D.: Evaluation of geophysical techniques for application in mountain permafrost studies, Z. Geomorphol. Supp., 132, 159–188, 2003. Hausmann,~H., Krainer,~K., Brückl,~E., and Mostler,~W.: Internal structure and ice content of Reichenkar rock glacier (Stubai Alps, Austria) assessed by geophysical investigations, Permafrost Periglac., 18(4), 351–367, 2007. Hilbich,~C.: Geophysical monitoring systems to assess and quantify ground ice evolution in mountain permafrost, Ph.D. thesis, Department of Geography, University of Jena, 173~pp., online available at: http://www.db-thueringen.de/servlets/DocumentServlet?id=13905, 2009. Hilbich,~C., Hauck,~C., Hoelzle,~M., Scherler,~M., Schudel,~L., Völksch, ~I., Vonder Mühll,~D., and Mäusbacher,~R.: Monitoring mountain permafrost evolution using electrical resistivity tomography: A~7-year study of seasonal, annual, and long-term variations at Schilthorn, Swiss Alps, J. Geophys. Res., 113, F01S90, doi:10.1029/2007JF000799, 2008. Ikeda,~A.: Combination of conventional geophysical methods for sounding the composition of rock glaciers in the Swiss Alps, Permafrost Periglac., 17(1), 35–48, 2006. Imhof,~M., Pierrehumbert,~G., Haeberli,~W., and Kienholz,~H.: Permafrost investigation in the Schilthorn massif, Bernese Alps, Switzerland, Permafrost Periglac., 11, 189–206, 2000. King,~M S.: Rock-physics developments in seismic exploration: a~personal 50-year perspective, Geophysics, 70(6), 3–8, 2005. Kneisel,~C., Hauck,~C., Fortier,~R., and Moorman,~B.: Advances in geophysical methods for permafrost investigations, Permafrost Periglac., 19(2), 157–178, 2008. Lambiel,~C.: Inventaire des glaciers rocheux entre la Val de Bages et le Val d'Hérémence (Valais), Ph.D. thesis, University of Lausanne, 167~pp., 1999. Landrø,~M., Nguyen,~A K., and Mehdizadeh,~H.: Time lapse refraction seismic – a~tool for monitoring carbonate fields?, in: SEG International Exposition and 74th Annual Meeting, 10–15~October 2004, Denver, Colorado, 1–4, 2004. Lanz,~E., Maurer,~H., and Green,~A G.: Refraction tomography over a~buried waste disposal site, Geophysics, 63(4), 1414–1433, 1998. Maurer,~H. and Hauck,~C.: Geophysical imaging of alpine rock glaciers, J. Glaciol., 53(180), 110–120, 2007. Musil,~M., Maurer,~H., Green,~A G., Horstmeyer,~H., Nitsche,~F O., Vonder Mühll,~D., and Springman,~S.: Shallow seismic surveying of an Alpine rock glacier, Geophysics, 67(6), 1701–1710, 2002. PERMOS: Permafrost in Switzerland 2004/2005 and 2005/2006, in: Glaciological Report (Permafrost) No 6/7 of the Cryospheric Commission (CC) of the Swiss Academy of Sciences (SCNAT) and the Department of Geography, edited by: Noetzli,~J., Naegeli,~B., and Vonder Mühll,~D., University of Zurich, 61~pp., 2009. Reynolds,~J M.: An Introduction to Applied and Environmental Geophysics, Wiley, Chichester, 796~pp., 1997. Röthlisberger,~H.: Seismic Exploration in Cold Regions, Cold Regions Research and Engineering Laboratory, Hanover, 139~pp., 1972. Sandmeier,~K J.: REFLEXW – Windows\texttrademark 9x/NT/2000/XP-program for the processing of seismic, acoustic or electromagnetic reflection, refraction and transmission data, 2008. Scott,~W J., Sellmann,~P V., and Hunter,~J A.: Geophysics in the study of permafrost, in: Geotechnical and Environmental Geophysics, edited by: Ward,~S., Society of Exploration Geophysics, Tulsa, 355–384, 1990. Timur,~A.: Velocity of compressional waves in porous media at permafrost temperatures, Geophysics, 33(4), 584–595, 1968. Vesnaver,~A L., Accainoz,~F., Bohmz,~G., Madrussaniz,~G., Pajchel,~J., Rossiz,~G., and Dal Moro,~G.: Time-lapse tomography, Geophysics, 68(3), 815–823, 2003. Vonder Mühll,~D., Noetzli,~J., Roer,~I., Makowski,~K., and Delaloye, ~R.: Permafrost in Switzerland 2002/2003 and 2003/2004, Glaciological Report (Permafrost) No. 4/5 of the Cryospheric Commission (CC) of the Swiss Academy of Sciences (SCNAT) and the Department of Geography, University of Zurich, 106, 2007. Vonder Mühll,~D S.: Geophysikalische Untersuchungen im Permafrost des Oberengadins, Ph.D. thesis, ETH Zürich, Diss. ETH Nr 10107, 222~pp., 1993. Wyllie,~M R J., Gregory,~A R., and Gardner,~L W.: Elastic wave velocities in heterogeneous and porous media, Geophysics, XXI(1), 41–70, 1956. Zimmerman,~R W. and King,~M S.: The effect of the extent of freezing on seismic velocities in unconsolidated permafrost, Geophysics, 51(6), 1285–1290, 1986.